LRN 131.02: Thinking About Science (G DEC)


TU/TH 11:20-12:40, Humanities New 3020

TH 12:50-2:10 (Recitation), SBS N310

Fall 2005

 

Instructor:       Rachel V. Kutz-Flamenbaum

E-mail:            rflamenb@ic.sunysb.edu

Office:            SBS N-427 (Department of Sociology)

Office Hours: Tues 1-2, Thurs 10:30-11:15, and by appointment.  

Phone:             You may leave a message for me at 631-632-7700


About the course:

            This course has been designed to meet several different objectives. It has been designed to serve as a link between your other courses– helping you connect with your fellow classmates in order to maximize your success in your courses and in college overall. Most of you will see your LRN classmates in your other classes. This course will provide an opportunity for you to connect with one another, develop study groups, and seek extra help in problem areas. It is also designed to introduce you to the resources and opportunities available at Stony Brook. This course has been constructed to facilitate the development of good study skills, writing skills, critical thinking skills and other academic skills essential for success in college.

            This Linking Seminar will be an unusual and exciting course where each student will be challenged to learn new skills, think about new ideas and express these ideas verbally and in writing. The theme for this semester is “Religion and Science”. Drawing on a wide range of reading, assignments and class-activities, we will explore the various manifestations of the tension between science and religion. Our exploration of this relationship will integrate several different academic disciplines: biology, physics, history, philosophy, sociology and political science. Class activities and assignments have been developed to encourage the development of critical thinking skills and communication skills.


Required Reading (The books have been ordered at both Stony Books and the Campus Bookstore. The reader is only available at Stony Books):

 

1.         Dan Brown’s Angel’s and Demon’s ( 2000, Pocket Star Books.)

 

2.         Paul Kurtz’s (editor) Science and Religion: Are they compatible? (2003, Prometheus Books.)

 

3.         Compiled by Rachel Kutz-Flamenbaum, Readings on Science & Religion.


Recommended Supplies:

Separate notebook/folder for journal

Binder (for class notes, syllabus, assignments and handouts)

Planner (calendar)


Readings:

            You are required to complete all readings by the day they are listed on the syllabus. Some readings will be distributed in class. Even if you miss class, you are still responsible for completing these readings on time. In order to encourage full participation in discussions, you are expected to bring the day’s readings with you to class. Any changes to the assigned readings will be announced in class and over the listserve.


Class Participation and Attendance and In-Class Projects (15%):  

            This is not a lecture based class. I encourage you to offer your ideas, opinions and thoughts in class. This class will benefit from the active participation of students. This class is a collaborative effort. Everyone should expect to offer his/her thoughts and opinions in every class. Repeated absences or failure to participate will result in a grade reduction. Most excused absences require advance approval from instructor and/or a doctor’s note. In the case of extenuating circumstances (accidents, death in the family...) please speak with me immediately.

            Over the course of the semester, we will conduct several in-class group projects. The projects will build upon readings and themes discussed in class and will provide a fun opportunity to put what you have learned in class to use. The projects may involve library work, social scientific observation, a set of questions to clarify readings and other critical skills.


Journal (15%):

            The purpose of your journal is to encourage reflexivity and thoughtfulness about your college experience and coursework. Journal assignments include reflection pieces on course material and campus experiences. One benefit to the journal entries is that they will give you an initial opportunity to think through essay topics. Each journal entry should be 1-2 type written (double spaced) pages or the handwritten equivalent. You may use either a notebook for handwritten reflections or a folder for typewritten comments. Journal assignments should be completed in approximately the same order as listed in the journal assignment list. In addition to the assignments included on the list, additional topics will be announced in class in response to films, readings, activities and events. Journal topics are attached as the last page of this syllabus.

            You should complete a minimum of one journal entry each week. At each collection date, I will check to make sure you have been working on the assigned topics. Rushed completion the day before the journal is due will be obvious in its (poor) quality.

            Journals will be graded primarily on their completion and degree of reflexivity and thoughtfulness. There are no right or wrong answers. Journals with fewer than 16 entries are not eligible for an A. Additional entries will count as extra credit and can be used to bolster your final grade. Journals will be collected three times during the semester with a final grade assigned at the final collection. See the syllabus for collection dates.

            

Critical Essays (4-3 page essays– each worth 10%. Total 40%):

            The majority of your grade for this course will be earned through writing four critical essays. Each of these essays should be 3 type-written pages and follow a formal essay style. Outlines and notes are unacceptable as completed essays. See comment on writing for more specific information. Several weeks before the paper is due, I will provide a written assignment. These assignments are designed to challenge you to think critically about readings and the world around you. Each assignment will draw on readings as well as some external information. We will talk more about essays when the specific topics are distributed.

            The deadlines for the critical essays reflect the LAST day an essay may be handed in. Students who wish to get ahead on their work should hand them in sooner. I will not accept any late essays. Essays which receive a C or lower may be re-written. Deadlines for re-writes will be announced in class.


Group Research Project (25%):

            The group project will be an opportunity for you to conduct research about a topic of particular interest. You will be assigned to a group based on topic of interest. Each group will chose a topic, research articles and books which inform the topic, write a 2-3 page description of findings and present the research to the class. These summaries will be presented to the class during the last week of class. Creativity is highly encouraged. Your grade for this part of the class will be calculated though a combination of instructor’s, group member’s and personal assessment.


Conferences & Self-Assessment (5%):

            Each student will meet with me a minimum of three times during the semester. While I’ll provide specific appointment times, it is your responsibility to keep the appointment. At the midterm and final conferences, you are required to calculate (based on the percentages below) your grade in the course. You are also required to calculate what grade you think you deserve. The grades you give to yourself will be calculated as part of your final grade.


Grades:

            Critical Essays (10 % each)                                        40%

            Group Research Project                                              25%

            Attendance, Participation and Class Projects             15%

            Journal                                                                        15%

            Conferences & Self-Assessment                                5%

 

Special Needs:

            If you have a physical, psychological, medical or learning disability that may impact your course work, please contact Disability Support Services, ECC (Educational Communications Center) Building, room128, (631) 632-6748. They will determine with you what accommodations are necessary and appropriate. All information and documentation is confidential. Students requiring emergency evacuation are encouraged to discuss their needs with their professors and Disability Support Services. For procedures and information, go to the following web site: http://www.ehs.sunysb.edu/fire/disabilities/asp.


Comment on writing:

            One of the goals of this class is to facilitate students’ development of writing and communication skills. All papers must be typewritten, double-spaced, proof-read and spell-checked. Cited material must include full citations, including page references and date of publication. A good reference for citation styles as well as grammatical information is the Manual of Style (Manual of Style. 1993. 14th edition. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press). I do not have a citation preference for your work, but you must be consistent.

There are many resources for developing your writing skills. There are writing manuals such as Strunk and White’s The Elements of Style (2000. 4th edition. Needham Heights, MA: Allyn & Bacon) and the aforementioned Chicago Manual of Style. A selection of such manuals should be available at the library. Additionally, please take advantage of the on-campus writing center. Information about their location and hours as well as additional resources may be found at their web page: http://naples.cc.stonybrook.edu/CAS/writingcenter1.nsf/. Finally, I am willing to look at rough drafts of essays provided I receive them at least three classes in advance of the assignment due date and students schedule a meeting to receive feedback in person.


Academic Honesty:

            All work you submit must be your own. By behaving in an dishonest fashion you do yourself, the true author, the class and instructor a disservice. I encourage you to incorporate outside sources in your work as you see fit but will not tolerate plagiarism or cheating. You must use proper citations for any direct ideas, quotes or data you include in your work. If you have some doubt as to what is acceptable please contact me or review the University guidelines found on the web at: http://naples.cc.sunysb.edu/CAS/ajc.nsf/pages/info.


Comment on Courtesy:

            This will be a discussion oriented class. In order for that to work effectively, all students must honor the requirements of basic courtesy. I expect you to:

        Arrive at class on time and stay the entire class period.

          If you need to leave early or arrive late, inform me in advance if possible and leave during a break in discussion keeping noise to a minimum.

        Turn off all cellphones before the beginning of class.

        Wait until there is a pause in the conversation before trying to add your thoughts. You should raise your hand and wait for me to call on you. You will be given time to share your idea but do not interrupt me or one of your classmates.

        Respect that everyone has ideas and opinions and not try to dominate the conversation.

          When you are in class, you need to only do class work. Do not play with palm pilots, cell phones or video games. Do not read material for other classes.


















Readings and Assignment Due Dates:

The following course outline will provide you with many of the important dates you need. Please be advised that this is a tentative reading and assignment schedule. Changes will be made to adjust to the speed and interests of our class.

 

Tues 8/30       Course Introduction - Syllabus As Contract

Assignment:   Bring copy of schedule to submit on Thurs.

Enter all important dates in planner (exams, paper due dates, extra credit lectures...)

 

Thurs 9/1       Reader:          “Understanding Your Prof’s Expectations”

                                                “The Syllabus as Contract”


                        Recitation: Individual Conferences in SBS N-427

 

Tues 9/6         Learning About Your Learning

Assignment:   Complete Learning Styles Assessment (http://www.engr.ncsu.edu/learningstyles/ilsweb.html)

                        Print finding and bring to class

                        Reader:           Learning Styles readings

                                                “Religious Community and American Individualism”

 

Thurs 9/8       What is Religion?

                        Reader:           “Religion in Africa”

 

                        Essay #1 Assigned

 

Tues 9/13       What is Science?

                        Reader:           “The Nature & Philosophy of Science”

 

Thurs 9/15     Reader:           Raman “Faith and Doubt”

 

Tues 9/20       The Relationship between Science and Religion

                        Reader:           Writings on Religion & Science

                        Kurtz:             “An Overview of the Issues” (Chap 1)

                        

                        Group Project Topics

                        Essay #1 Due

 

Thurs 9/22     Reader:           “Science Finds God”

 

Tues 9/27       Library Visit 

                        Reader:           “Messages from Heaven”       

 

Thurs 9/29     Kurtz:             “Are Science and Religion Conflicting or Complementary?” (Chap2)

                                                “Designer Universe” (Chap. 3)


                        Essay #2 Assigned

 

Tues 10/4 Rosh Hashanah - No Class

 

Thurs 10/6     Angels and Demons    Chap. 1-25

 

Tues 10/11     Angels and Demons Chap. 26-50


Thurs 10/13 Yom Kippur - No Class

 

Tues 10/18     Angels and Demons Chap 51-85

                        

                        Essay #2 Due

 

Thurs 10/20   Midterm Conferences: Assignment (bring to conference): Calculate your grade for this class at this point in semester based on course requirements in syllabus. If you were giving yourself a grade what would it be and why? Apply these calculations to your other classes as well.


                        Angels and Demons Chap 86-end

 

Tues 10/25     Kurtz:             “Science and Religion in Historical Perspective”

                                                “The Galileo Affair”

 

Thurs 10/27   Reader:           Galileo Materials

 

Tues 11/1       No New Reading Assigned


                        Essay #3 Assigned

 

Thurs 11/3     Reader:           “The Search for the Philosopher’s Stone”

 

Tues 11/8       Reader:           “The Sorcerer’s Apprentice”

                                                “The Next Einstein? Applicants Welcome”

 

Thurs 11/10   Kurtz:             “Creationism versus Evolution” (chap 9)

                                                “Design Yes, Intelligent No” (chap 11)

 

Tues 11/15     Kurtz:             “A World Designed By God” (chap 13)

                        Reader:           SKIM “Creation Triumphs Over Evolution”

                                                Intelligent Design Materials

                        

                        Essay #3 Due

 

Thurs 11/17   No New Reading Due

 

Tues 11/22     Kurtz:             “Where the Two Worlds Tangle” (chap 23)

                        Reader:           “Birth After Death”


                        Group Project Draft Due

 

Thurs 11/24               Thanksgiving - No Class

 

Tues 11/29     Kurtz:             “Science and the Unknowable” (chap 35)

                                                “Celebrating Creation” (chap 37) 

 

Thurs 12/1     Kurtz:             “Science and Religion in an Impersonal Universe” (chap 38)

                        Essay #4 Assigned 

 

Tues 12/6       Group Project Presentations

 

Thurs 12/8     Group Project Presentations

 

Tues 12/13     Plans for Next Semester


Final Essay Due 12/20 by 11 am under door of my office SBS N-427


 







 


Journal Topics:

 

1.         What are your goals for college? What is your plan for achieving these goals?

2.         Reflections on your first week of college.

3.         What is your learning style? What did you learn about yourself? How can you use this knowledge to succeed in college?

4.         What is science? What is religion? How do you think they might relate?

5.         Reflection on the idea of a “designer universe”.

6.         Reflection on the group dynamics of an in-class group project. What role did you take? How were tasks divided?


                                                Due 9/27

 

7.         How are your study skills? Reflect on your study plan and a recent exam result.

8.         Attend an on campus lecture. Reflect on the event’s content.

9.         Take an hour and use the internet to research a topic of your choosing. Write a brief report of your findings and analyze your web searching skills.

10.       What do you think it is about Angel’s and Demons that makes it so popular?

11.       Do you think that Galileo should have been found guilty? Why?

12.       Watch a one hour action drama or action movie. What elements of similarity do you see between the show/movie & Angel’s and Demons?


                                                Due 10/27

 

13.       Reflect on a recent group activity. How have the group dynamics changed? What new skills have you learned?

14.       Attend a cultural, political or social event on campus (dance performance, political group meeting...). Reflect on the event’s content.

15.       How have your ideas about science and religion changed? What do you think is the future of their relationship?


                                                Due 11/29


Additional topics will be announced in class and will include reactions to films, readings and campus events.